10 Best Islands in Florida

Florida beckons as a beacon for travelers from around the globe, presenting a kaleidoscope of sandy shores, thrilling theme parks, and vibrant cities under the banner of the Sunshine State. The allure isn’t just in the well-known metropolises of Orlando and Miami; it’s also in its scattered, stunning islands. Each island serves as a unique world unto itself, promenading a host of experiences that range from the serenity of secluded beaches to the vibrant rhythms echoing from locales that feel a world apart from the contiguous United States, yet are connected by the convenience of bridges—an invitation to those journeying by land.

Venture beyond the mainland and discover a collection of Florida’s finest islands, each accessible with the simple crossing of a bridge. Here, the subtropical embrace of the coast sweeps you away to settings where every isle has a story, whether nestled secretly away from the tourist throngs or pulsing with a culture that is closer in heartbeat to Havana than to Miami. The islands await as stunning juxtapositions of nature and nurture, offering up not just a destination, but experiences treasured and ripe for discovery.

1. Key Biscayne Insider View

Experience the tranquility of Key Biscayne—a serene haven just a stone’s throw from Miami’s energy. On this barrier island, the pace slows, and life’s simpler pleasures come into focus. Embrace southern Florida’s allure with an active day on the island:

• Crandon Park Beach: Stroll along a three-mile expanse of pristine sand.
• Bill Baggs State Park: Paddle through serene waters or ascend the lighthouse for panoramic views.
• Recreational Pathways: Lace up for a jog or cycle along miles of scenic trails by the shore.

Key Biscayne isn’t just serene; it’s a tropical playground where the warmth of the sea invites you to linger.

2. Exploring Gasparilla Island

Stumble upon Gasparilla Island, a slice of tranquility nestled off Florida’s west coast. Here, you can reconnect with an untouched version of the Sunshine State. Legend whispers of the island’s namesake, a pirate of Spanish origin, hinting at a history both rich and mysterious.

• Embrace serenity at Boca Grande Beach, where waves gently kiss your feet with cool, refreshing embraces.
• Navigate the Boca Grande Bike Trail and find yourself amidst an aviary spectacle, a feast for bird enthusiasts.
• Port Boca Grande Lighthouse stands guard at the island’s southern tip, its light first piercing the dusk in 1890, a beacon for decades of seafarers.

Let the island’s laid-back spirit rejuvenate you as you bask in its natural and historical treasures.

3. Siesta Key

Nestled in the embrace of the Gulf of Mexico, you’ll find Siesta Key off Sarasota’s shores. This barrier island boasts an expansive stretch of fine white sand, a public beach acclaimed as a jewel within the United States.

Visitors flock to this 8-mile long shoreline for the quintessential beach day: basking under the sun and embracing the ocean’s embrace. Beyond the sands, Ocean Boulevard is peppered with unique local restaurants, lively bars, and quaint shops where you can hunt for mementos. Here, every moment becomes a memory as you immerse yourself in Siesta Key’s laid-back yet enchanting island life.

See Related: Best Beach Resorts in Florida

4. Key Largo: A Diver’s First Stop

Engulfed by the gentle embrace of turquoise waters, Key Largo welcomes you as the threshold to the Florida Keys’ splendor. Known to some as simply a point of passage, this island holds its own as a sanctuary for underwater adventurers.

At John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park, you can plunge into an aquatic world renowned for scuba diving. Embrace the clarity of the ocean as you discover the vibrant dance of coral formations. For a more secluded exploration, arrange a guided escapade beyond the shoreline into the water’s wilder depths. Here, Key Largo doesn’t just whisper a call to divers—it resounds with opportunities to delve into nature’s submerged gallery.

5. Exploring Anna Maria Island

Off the Gulf Coast, nestled south of Tampa, you’ll find the charms of Anna Maria Island beckoning. This coastal gem is a haven for beachgoers, with Bradenton Beach and Coquina Beach offering pristine stretches of sand—perfect for a refreshing swim or an afternoon sculpting sandcastles.

The essence of “Old Florida” thrives here. The island maintains its historical roots with restored buildings and local lore that paint a picture of its past inhabitants, from the Timucuan Indians to Spanish explorers. Take time to wander through the Anna Maria Island Historical Society to uncover the rich tapestry of stories woven into the island’s heritage.

• Beaches to Visit:

  • Bradenton Beach
  • Coquina Beach

• Local Tip:

  • For a slice of history, visit the Anna Maria Island Historical Society.

6. Marco Island

Crossing the bridge from Naples, Florida, you’ll find yourself on Marco Island, a thriving coastal gem nestled at the threshold of the Everglades. This isle is not just a base for exploring the wilds of the nearby national park; it stands as a serene getaway with its own urban charm. The skyline, peppered with elegant high-rises, outlines the horizon where sky meets sea, offering you magnificent vistas.

Key Highlights:

• Ocean Excursions: Set sail on the turquoise waters for an intimate dolphin encounter or join a spirited deep-sea fishing adventure.
• Pristine Beaches: Marvel at the fiery hues of sunset at South Marco Beach, and indulge in a shell-seeking stroll along Tigertail Beach—an unspoken treasure trove for shell collectors.
• Natural Beauty: With the lush Everglades as its backdrop, immerse yourself in the island’s rich tapestry of nature and wildlife.

As you meander through the island, each view competes for your gaze, from the ocean’s grandeur to the intricate beauty of seashells adorning Tigertail Beach. Your visit to Marco Island is not just a trip; it’s an entry into a coastal haven where city life and nature coalesce.

See Related: Top Places to Visit in Florida

7. Islamorada: A Fishing Haven and Snorkeler’s Delight

Nestled about halfway from Miami to Key West, you’ll discover Islamorada, spanning the keys of Tea Table, Plantation, and both Lower and Upper Matecumbe. Affectionately known as a mecca for sport fishing, here, whether you’re an expert angler or just dabbling, the allure of the big catch is omnipresent.

Venture off the Overseas Highway to Bahia Honda State Park, where you can snorkel in crystal-clear waters. Close by, plunge into an unforgettable encounter at Theater of the Sea, where swimming with dolphins and sea lions isn’t just a dream.

8. Unveiling Sanibel Island’s Charm

Wander along the shores of Sanibel Island and your toes will unearth treasures of the sea—shards of colorful shells and keen sand dollars. This Gulf of Mexico jewel, set along Florida’s western coastline, whispers the lure of a quieter, family-centric retreat.

• Beaches: Not your typical sugar-sand spectacle, these strands dazzle with shell-speckled sands.
• Sanibel Lighthouse: Explore the island’s revered beacon, guiding sailors since the late 1800s.
• Wildlife Refuge: Embrace nature at the J. N. “Ding” Darling National Wildlife Refuge, a birdwatcher’s paradise.

Allow yourself the simple joy of shell-collecting or behold the array of avian life that calls this island home. Sanibel isn’t just a backdrop for relaxation; it’s a tapestry of natural wonders, historical threads, and stories etched in shell-lined sands.

9. Exploring Amelia Island

Nestled in Florida’s northeast corner, you’ll discover Amelia Island, embracing the Atlantic with pristine shores beckoning sun-seekers. It’s more than just a beach getaway; Amelia Island is a playground for both land and sea adventures, with opportunities to tee off on premier golf courses or navigate through enchanting waters by boat.

Immerse yourself in history with a visit to the iconic Fort Clinch, perched on the coastline. This well-preserved bastion offers glimpses into the past, complemented by a museum rich in local lore. For nature enthusiasts, miles of trails ribbon through the area, ideal for uncovering the island’s serenity on foot.

See Related: Best Resorts in Key West, Florida

10. Discover Key West

Dip your toes into the perennial warmth of Key West, the jewel at the tip of Florida’s sun-kissed archipelago. No matter the month, this island pulses with a vibrant rhythm. Quench your thirst for history at the one-time haven of author Ernest Hemingway, or explore the storied chambers of the Harry S. Truman Little White House, steeped in presidential lore.

• Historic Sites:
  • Hemingway’s Home
  • Truman’s Winter White House

As the daylight wanes, Mallory Square transforms into an open-air stage where jugglers and musicians enchant. Later, sway down Duval Street, where seafood delights beckon and bars brim with life until dawn.

• Evening Activities:
  • Sunset at Mallory Square
  • Culinary exploration on Duval Street

Related Resources: 

• Most Romantic Places in the World
• Best Nature Destinations Around the World
• Best Travel Sites to Save Money and Travel More
• Best Travel Apps & Websites for Deals