St. Elmo Steak House is a historic steakhouse at 127 S Illinois Street in downtown Indianapolis’s Wholesale District, known for aged beef, an exceptionally fiery shrimp cocktail, and old-school dining rooms. Founded in 1902 by Joe Stahr, it remains a defining Indianapolis dinner reservation: a place for celebratory steaks, bourbon, and a direct connection to the city’s commercial and sporting history.
What to Expect at St. Elmo Steak House
The signature opening act is St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail: chilled shrimp beneath a red cocktail sauce charged with freshly ground horseradish. Its heat travels straight to the nose, so try a little sauce before taking an ambitious first bite. Follow it with filet mignon, ribeye, or New York strip; seafood gives non-steak eaters another route through the menu. Traditional accompaniments include navy bean soup or tomato juice with dinner entrées, while potatoes and vegetables round out the steakhouse experience.
Wood paneling, historic photographs, close-set dining tables, and experienced service give the restaurant its clubby character. This is an animated dining room, particularly when conventions, football weekends, and major downtown events overlap. The upstairs 1933 Lounge offers a separate, adults-only cocktail setting. Look for the Elmo Cola, combining cherry-and-vanilla-infused bourbon with cola, and a substantial wine selection suited to beef. For dietary restrictions, discuss ingredients and preparation directly with staff; a classic steakhouse menu does not automatically make sauces, sides, or shared cooking surfaces suitable for every allergy.
- Fiery shrimp cocktail: The restaurant’s defining appetizer delivers a sharp horseradish kick rather than lingering chili heat.
- Classic steak cuts: Filet mignon, ribeye, and New York strip anchor a traditional, beef-focused dinner.
- 1902 heritage: Historic photographs and dark-wood interiors connect the meal to more than a century of Indianapolis hospitality.
- 1933 Lounge: The upstairs, age-21-and-over lounge provides a cocktail-focused alternative to the main dining rooms.
- Take-home specialties: The official shop sells sauces, seasonings, bottled cocktails, and steaks shipped nationwide.
St. Elmo Steak House at a Glance
| Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Address | 127 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225 |
| Neighborhood / Area | Wholesale District, downtown Indianapolis |
| Operating Hours | Monday–Thursday 4–10 p.m.; Friday 4–11 p.m.; Saturday 3–11 p.m.; Sunday 4–9 p.m. |
| Admission / Price Range | $$$$; premium steakhouse dining, with drinks, tax, and gratuity additional. Check the official menu for current prices. |
| Recommended Visit Duration | 1.5 to 2.5 hours |
| Nearest Transit / Parking | IndyGo Route 8 on Washington Street; downtown transit center within walking distance. Valet and nearby Circle Centre garages. |
| Official Website & Phone | St. Elmo Steak House; +1 317-635-0636 |
Visiting Tips, Getting There & Nearby Pairings
Reserve through the official website well ahead for Friday and Saturday dinners, Indianapolis Colts home games, and major conventions. Opening-time reservations work well before an evening event; tell your server your departure deadline rather than assuming a full steak dinner can be rushed. Smart casual clothing fits the room, though jackets are common for celebrations. Budget for a premium meal and customary American table-service tipping; confirm payment arrangements when booking a large party.
IndyGo Route 8 runs along nearby Washington Street; the Julia M. Carson Transit Center at 201 E Washington Street is roughly a 12–15-minute walk. Drivers can use valet service or Circle Centre parking, checking event rates and garage closing times. Dining occupies multiple levels: wheelchair users should arrange accessible seating and confirm the step-free entrance and restroom route by phone, especially before booking upstairs. Pair dinner with Monument Circle, about eight minutes north, Gainbridge Fieldhouse, roughly seven minutes southeast, or Lucas Oil Stadium, approximately 12–15 minutes southwest.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the hours, and when should I visit?
St. Elmo opens at 4 p.m. Sunday through Friday and 3 p.m. Saturday, closing between 9 and 11 p.m. depending on the day. Choose an early weekday reservation for a less event-driven dinner, and check holiday schedules before traveling.
How expensive is dinner, and do I need reservations?
This is a $$$$ steakhouse, particularly when shrimp cocktail, wine, and additional sides join the order. Reservations are strongly recommended; consult the official menus for current item prices.
How much time should I allow?
Allow 1.5 to 2.5 hours for appetizers, steaks, and dessert. Add time for valet retrieval or a walk to a stadium, especially when downtown events finish or begin together.
Is St. Elmo suitable for families?
Families can dine in the main restaurant, although the pace and pricing suit a seated special-occasion meal. The upstairs 1933 Lounge is restricted to guests aged 21 and older; request main-restaurant seating when visiting with children.
When planning your Indianapolis travel guide or comparing verified nightlife and steak house in Indianapolis, pair this stop with standout local spots including Holliday Park, Livery, Union 50, and Le Méridien Indianapolis (nearby).
