Two Cities Pizza Co. is an award-winning pizzeria located at 202 W Main St in historic downtown Mason, Ohio, roughly 25 miles northeast of downtown Cincinnati. Founded in 2015 by childhood friends Zach Greves and Sean Spurlock inside Mason’s restored former City Hall and firehouse, the restaurant settles America’s great pizza debate by serving both authentic Chicago-style deep dish and foldable New York-style thin crust under one roof. Travelers visiting Warren County for Kings Island amusement park or the Cincinnati Open tennis tournament flock here for scratch-made pies, rotating regional craft beers on tap, and immersive big-city themed dining rooms.
What to Expect at Two Cities Pizza Co.
Stepping inside the historic brick building on West Main Street reveals an interior divided into distinct urban zones celebrating New York City and Chicago. Diners pass vintage subway tilework, exposed brick walls, custom graffiti murals, a replica New York subway car booth, and restrooms modeled after iconic city transit stops—complete with yellow taxi doors and elevated-train platform details. The kitchen prepares dough daily from scratch, allowing guests at the same table to order a buttery, flaky cornmeal-crust Chicago deep dish layered with Wisconsin mozzarella and chunky crushed-tomato marinara alongside a crisp, hand-tossed New York pie dusted with garlic and oregano.
Menu selections are named after famous streets and landmarks from both metropolises. On the Chicago deep-dish side, baked in seasoned deep pans to achieve a caramelized cheese edge, favorites include the Windy City (pepperoni, house-made Italian sausage, bacon, red onions, green peppers, and mushrooms) and the Magnificent Mile. On the New York thin-crust menu, the Wall Street pairs pepperoni, spicy capicola, Genoa salami, and creamy ricotta, while the Bleecker Street and Broadway showcase classic East Coast topping combinations. Gluten-free crusts, vegan cheese substitutions, shareable oven-baked knots, fresh chopped salads, and a full bar pouring Ohio craft IPAs, ciders, and signature cocktails round out the dining experience.
- Chicago Deep Dish Pies: Baked in deep pans with a rich, buttery crust, thick layers of pulled mozzarella, and chunky herb-seasoned tomato sauce ladled on top; available in individual and shareable sizes.
- New York Hand-Tossed Thin Crust: Wide, foldable slices brushed with garlic oil and topped with shredded mozzarella, tangy house pizza sauce, and premium meats or roasted vegetables.
- Subway & Taxi Themed Architecture: Converted from Mason’s historic municipal building, featuring an authentic NYC subway car dining area, Wrigley-inspired brickwork, and famous themed restrooms.
- Appetizers & Shareables: House-baked garlic Parmesan knots served with warm marinara, fiery buffalo chicken dip, and crisp salads ideal for splitting while deep-dish pies bake.
- Ohio Craft Beer & Full Bar: Rotating draft list highlighting Greater Cincinnati and Midwest breweries alongside classic cocktails and wines by the glass.
Two Cities Pizza Co. at a Glance
| Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Address | 202 W Main St, Mason, OH 45040 |
| Neighborhood / Area | Historic Downtown Mason (Warren County) |
| Operating Hours | Tue–Thu: 3:00 PM–10:00 PM; Fri–Sat: 11:00 AM–11:00 PM; Sun: 11:00 AM–10:00 PM; Mon: Closed |
| Admission / Price Range | $$ (Pizzas and mains typically $14–$32 depending on size and style) |
| Recommended Visit Duration | 1 to 1.5 hours (allow 30–40 minutes bake time for Chicago deep dish) |
| Nearest Transit / Parking | Free public parking lot behind the building off West Church Street and street parking along Main Street |
| Official Website & Phone | twocitiespizza.com | +1 513-770-0000 |
Visiting Tips, Getting There & Nearby Pairings
Because Two Cities Pizza Co. is one of the busiest dining spots in northern Cincinnati, joining the live online waitlist via twocitiespizza.com before heading to downtown Mason is essential on Friday and Saturday evenings as well as summer afternoons when Kings Island lets out. The restaurant does not take traditional weeks-ahead reservations for standard tables, operating instead through its real-time digital waitlist. If you prefer a quieter meal, arrive right at 11:00 AM on weekends or between 3:00 PM and 4:30 PM on Tuesday through Thursday. Remember that authentic Chicago deep dish requires 30 to 40 minutes in the oven, so ordering an appetizer of garlic knots shortly after being seated keeps the table satisfied.
Located at the corner of West Main Street (US-42) and West Church Street, the restaurant sits 10 minutes west of Interstate 71 (Exit 19 or Exit 24) and 10 minutes east of Interstate 75 (Tylersville Road exit). Free municipal parking is available directly behind the building off West Church Street, with additional angled spaces along Main Street. The ground-floor entrance, main dining room, bar, and themed restrooms are step-free and wheelchair accessible, with high chairs available for families. Before or after your meal, stroll along downtown Mason’s walkable Main Street corridor to visit local coffee shops and boutiques, walk 5 minutes east to Mason Historical Society’s Alverta Green Museum, or drive 10 minutes to Kings Island, Soak City Water Park, and the Lindner Family Tennis Center.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the opening hours and best times to visit Two Cities Pizza Co.?
Two Cities Pizza Co. is open Tuesday through Thursday from 3:00 PM to 10:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM; the restaurant is closed on Mondays. The calmest dining windows are weekday afternoons between 3:00 PM and 5:00 PM or early weekend lunches at 11:00 AM.
Does Two Cities Pizza Co. take reservations or offer an online waitlist?
Instead of standard advance reservations, the Mason location uses an online waitlist accessible directly through the official website. Guests are strongly encouraged to join the waitlist remotely 30 to 60 minutes before arriving on weekend nights, and online ordering is also available for carryout.
How much time should I budget for a meal at Two Cities Pizza Co.?
Plan to spend 60 to 90 minutes once seated. While New York thin-crust pies bake quickly, Chicago-style deep-dish pizzas are baked to order in deep pans and take approximately 30 to 40 minutes to reach the table.
Is Two Cities Pizza Co. family-friendly and wheelchair accessible?
Yes, the restaurant is very welcoming to families with children, offering booth and table seating, high chairs, and playful subway and taxi decor that kids enjoy exploring. The building features a step-free street-level entrance, accessible tables, and wheelchair-accessible restrooms.
When planning your Mason travel guide or browsing verified restaurants in Mason, pair this stop with standout local spots including Loveland Castle Museum, S.W. Clyborne Co. Provision & Spirits, The Mason Grill, and The Mason Historical Society (nearby).
