The Old Fashioned is a Wisconsin-focused tavern and restaurant at 23 North Pinckney Street, Madison, Wisconsin 53703, United States of America, on the northeast side of Capitol Square. Open since 2005, it turns the state’s tavern and supper-club traditions into a downtown meal: hand-muddled brandy Old Fashioneds, Wisconsin beer, fresh cheese curds, brats, burgers and fish. Travelers come for a distinctly local menu in a central location directly across from the Wisconsin State Capitol, convenient for lunch, a pre-show dinner or a Square-side drink.
What to Expect at The Old Fashioned
This is a busy, casual tavern rather than a formal supper club. Its identity is deliberately Wisconsin-specific: the official menu describes house-made fresh Wisconsin beer-battered cheese curds made with local fresh curds, while the restaurant’s beer program lists 50 Wisconsin beers on tap. Order the namesake Old Fashioned in the state’s customary brandy style, hand muddled and available sweet or sour, then settle in for substantial bar food and a downtown crowd that mixes Capitol visitors, University of Wisconsin fans and Madison regulars.
Inside, dark wood, vintage-style tavern signage and a compact bar-and-dining-room layout evoke a mid-century Wisconsin bar. The food menu is the main collection of regional reference points: cheese curds, a shareable Lazy Susan inspired by the supper-club relish tray, brats, burgers and walleye. Friday fish fry is another classic choice. There are no museum exhibits or guided tours here; the experience is the menu, the beer taps and the view of Capitol Square just outside the door.
- House-made cheese curds: Fresh local Wisconsin curds in a beer batter, promoted by the restaurant as its signature starter.
- Wisconsin Old Fashioneds: Hand-muddled brandy cocktails served sweet or sour in the state tradition.
- 50 Wisconsin beers on tap: A tap list focused on breweries and regional labels from across the state.
- Supper-club references: The Lazy Susan share plate recalls a relish tray with spreads, pickled vegetables and cheese.
- Capitol Square setting: A doorstep location for pairing a meal with the Wisconsin State Capitol, State Street or an Overture Center performance.
The Old Fashioned at a Glance
| Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Address | 23 N Pinckney St #1, Madison, WI 53703 |
| Neighborhood / Area | Capitol Square, downtown Madison; across from the Wisconsin State Capitol |
| Operating Hours | Mon–Thu 11 a.m.–9 p.m.; Fri 11 a.m.–10 p.m.; Sat 9 a.m.–10 p.m.; Sun closed |
| Admission & Ticket Prices | No admission or tickets; pay for food and drinks. See the official website for current menu and ordering details. |
| Recommended Visit Duration | 1 to 1.5 hours for a meal and drinks |
| Nearest Transit / Parking | Metro Transit stops around Capitol Square are nearby; Capitol Square North Garage is a short walk away. |
| Official Website / Phone | theoldfashioned.com / (608) 310-4545 |
Visiting Tips, Getting There & Nearby Pairings
For the easiest seating, target a weekday lunch or a mid-afternoon meal. Weekend evenings, Badger football Saturdays and Saturday mornings during the Dane County Farmers’ Market season can bring waits. The restaurant is closed Sundays. There is no ticket or admission reservation to arrange; use the restaurant’s online ordering page for pickup and call for current seating or group questions. Menu prices and availability can change, so confirm them before visiting.
Metro Transit buses stop around Capitol Square, within a few minutes on foot; check the current Metro trip planner for the best route from your hotel or campus. Driving is less convenient because curbside spaces around the Square are limited; the Capitol Square North Garage is generally the practical nearby option. The restaurant has a wheelchair-accessible entrance, and the approach from Capitol Square uses paved city sidewalks; guests needing confirmation of table clearances, restroom access or a particular seating arrangement should call before arrival. Within a 5–15 minute walk, tour the Wisconsin State Capitol, walk State Street toward the University of Wisconsin campus, or reach the Overture Center for the Arts on State Street.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are The Old Fashioned’s hours, and when is the best time to go?
It opens at 11 a.m. Monday through Friday, at 9 a.m. Saturday, and is closed Sunday. Weekday lunch and mid-afternoon are usually the best choices for avoiding the biggest crowds; allow extra time on football Saturdays and Farmers’ Market mornings.
Does The Old Fashioned charge admission or take reservations?
There is no admission fee or ticket price. Guests pay for food and drinks. Contact the restaurant at (608) 310-4545 for current seating and group-arrangement information; pickup orders are available online.
How much time should I budget for a visit?
Plan on 1 to 1.5 hours for cheese curds, a main dish and a drink. Add time if you arrive during a peak period or want to continue with a Capitol tour, State Street walk or nearby performance.
Is The Old Fashioned suitable for families and wheelchair users?
Families can find familiar tavern fare such as burgers, brats and cheese curds, though the atmosphere can become loud during peak service. The entrance is wheelchair accessible; call ahead to discuss seating, restroom needs or stroller space in the compact dining room.
When planning your Madison travel guide or comparing verified restaurants and nightlife in Madison, pair this stop with standout local spots including Monty's Blue Plate Diner, La Taguara, Toby's Supper Club, and Sol's on the Square (nearby).
