Destination Guide: Explore Utica Guide

Don Antonio

Don Antonio

Practical Information & Visitor Guide

4.6 (1,533 reviews)
Known For

Wood-fired Neapolitan pizza, the fried-and-baked Montanara Starita, and Naples-rooted pizzaiolo tradition.

Address
309 W 50th St, New York, NY 10019, New York, New York, 10019, United States of America
Hours
  • Monday: 11:30AM-10PM
  • Tuesday: 11:30AM-10PM
  • Wednesday: 11:30AM-10PM
  • Thursday: 11:30AM-10PM
  • Friday: 11:30AM-10PM
  • Saturday: 11:30AM-10PM
  • Sunday: 11:30AM-10PM
Admission & Pricing
$$ No admission; pay for food and drinks ordered.
Visit Duration
45 to 75 minutes
Accessibility
Midtown curb-cut sidewalks support wheelchair and stroller approaches; contact Don Antonio before arrival for current entry and seating arrangements.
Official Website
www.donantoniopizza.com

Highlights & Amenities

  • Montanara Starita
  • wood-fired oven
  • Giorgia Caporuscio-led kitchen
  • gluten-free pizza options
  • Italian craft beers
  • seasonal cocktails

Ideal For

Broadway theatergoers Neapolitan pizza enthusiasts Couples Small groups
Style: Food & Culinary Nightlife & Entertainment
Audience: Couples Foodies
Season: Year-round

Don Antonio is a Neapolitan pizzeria and full bar at 309 W 50th St, New York, NY 10019, in Hell’s Kitchen near the Theatre District in New York, United States of America. Opened in 2012 by pizzaiolo Roberto Caporuscio and Antonio Starita of Naples’ historic Starita a Materdei, it draws Broadway audiences and pizza-focused travelers for wood-fired pies, pizza fritta and Italian drinks. The current kitchen is led by award-winning master pizzaiola Giorgia Caporuscio, continuing the family’s Naples-rooted approach.

What to Expect at Don Antonio

The centerpiece is the traditional Italian wood-fired oven, which gives the restaurant’s Neapolitan pizzas their softly charred, blistered rims and tender centers. The standout signature experience is the Montanara Starita: dough is lightly fried first, then topped with tomato sauce and smoked mozzarella before being finished in the oven. It has a crisp, airy exterior that distinguishes it from a conventional baked pie. Classic Margherita-style pizzas sit alongside a broader specialty-pizza menu, while fried appetizers provide a useful first course for a table sharing several pies.

Don Antonio is a casual, active Midtown dining room rather than a destination for a long, formal dinner. It is particularly well placed before or after a show, with Broadway theaters a few blocks east. The drinks program includes Italian craft beers, wine and seasonal cocktails, making it a practical choice for a full meal or a pizza-and-drink stop. Gluten-free pizza options are available. The restaurant welcomes walk-ins and does not take reservations, so timing matters more than advance booking.

  • Montanara Starita: Lightly fried pizza finished in the wood-fired oven with tomato sauce and smoked mozzarella.
  • Neapolitan lineage: Founded with Antonio Starita, whose family operates Naples’ Starita a Materdei, established in 1901.
  • Wood-fired pizzas: Traditional Italian oven baking for classic and specialty Neapolitan pies.
  • Giorgia Caporuscio’s kitchen: The acclaimed master pizzaiola leads the current pizza program.
  • Full bar: Italian craft beer, wine and seasonal cocktails pair with the food menu.

Don Antonio at a Glance

DetailInformation
Address309 W 50th St, New York, NY 10019
Neighborhood / AreaHell’s Kitchen, beside the Theatre District in Midtown Manhattan
Operating HoursDaily, 11:30 a.m.–10 p.m.; check the official website for holiday or service updates.
Admission & Ticket PricesNo admission or tickets; pay for food and drinks ordered.
Recommended Visit Duration45–75 minutes for a meal; allow extra time during pre-theater rushes.
Nearest Transit / ParkingC or E to 50 St at Eighth Avenue, about one block away; 1 to 50 St at Broadway is also walkable. Nearby commercial garages offer paid parking.
Official Website / Phonedonantoniopizza.com / 646-719-1043

Visiting Tips, Getting There & Nearby Pairings

Arrive for an early lunch or after Broadway curtains rise if you want the best chance of a shorter walk-in wait. The busiest period is generally the pre-theater window, especially on Wednesday, Saturday and Sunday matinee days, when diners need to eat before evening performances. There are no reservations to book; join the walk-in queue and leave enough time before a curtain. Pizza travels well for takeout, but the Montanara is at its best immediately after it leaves the oven, when its fried-and-baked crust is crispest.

The closest subway choice is the 50 St station on the C and E lines at Eighth Avenue; from there, walk east along West 50th Street. The 1 train’s 50 St stop at Broadway is another straightforward approach. Midtown sidewalks are paved and curb cuts support wheelchair and stroller travel, though the restaurant’s close-set dining room can be busy at peak times. Contact Don Antonio before arrival to discuss entry and table-access needs through its accessibility page or by phone. Broadway theaters are within a 5–10 minute walk, Times Square is roughly 10 minutes east, and the waterfront paths of Hudson River Park are about 15 minutes west.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are Don Antonio’s hours, and when is the best time to go?

Don Antonio is open daily from 11:30 a.m. to 10 p.m. Go at weekday lunch, early afternoon, or after 8 p.m. for a more relaxed walk-in experience. Pre-theater dining brings the heaviest demand.

Does Don Antonio charge admission or take reservations?

There is no admission charge or ticket requirement; guests pay for menu items. Don Antonio does not take reservations, so all dine-in visits are walk-in based.

How much time should I budget for a meal?

Plan on 45 to 75 minutes for pizza, appetizers and drinks. Add waiting time before Broadway performances, particularly on weekends and matinee days.

Is Don Antonio suitable for families and wheelchair users?

Families can share pizzas and choose from fried starters and gluten-free pizza options. Strollers and wheelchairs can use Midtown’s curb-cut sidewalks; call ahead for current seating and entry arrangements, especially during busy service periods.

When planning your Utica travel guide or browsing verified restaurants in Utica, pair this stop with standout local spots including Utica Zoo, Ocean Blue Restaurant & Oyster Bar, Roscoe Conkling Park, and Delacorte Clock (1.4 km away).

🏨 Find Places to Stay Nearby

Compare top hotels, apartments, and vacation rentals with live pricing & availability.

Loading interactive accommodation map…

🎟️ Top Tours & Experiences in Utica

Book verified guided tours, skip-the-line museum tickets, and outdoor excursions with free cancellation.

GetYourGuide Verified

Explore Top Rated Activities in Utica

Find highly-rated day trips, walking tours, boat cruises, and landmark entry passes.

Browse Experiences ↗

📍 More Places to Explore in This Destination

Discover more verified attractions, sights, and hidden gems nearby.

Data Source: google_places • Recorded check: 2026-11-15

How Our Travel Guides Are Built

📍 Explore Places

Browse destinations and place listings to build your shortlist. Follow available source links for more detail.

🕒 Check Before You Go

Hours, prices, access rules, and availability can change. Confirm time-sensitive details directly with the venue.

🧭 Plan Your Visit

Use addresses and destination guides to compare locations, then check transport and booking options for your travel dates.

Keep Exploring Destinations

Browse destination guides, practical travel information, and inspiring places for your next trip.